Which is better, Shimano's older generation higher grade brakes or the current lower grade brakes?
Posted at: Mar. 19, 2021
Which is better, Shimano's older generation higher grade brakes or the current lower grade brakes? This article examines Shimano's brake technology and the year they were released.
Table of contents
Sponsored Link
Shimano Brake Technology
First, let’s check out the technology used in Shimano’s brakes of the past.
SLR-EV
Shimano's 105 brake BR-R7000 with SLR-EV
Shimano’s latest brake technology is this SLR-EV. It is a conventional dual-pivot system, but with three fulcrum points for increased rigidity. The amount of pull on the brake lever is compatible with the NEW SUPER SLR.
The current SORA BR-R3000 brake is the NEW SUPER SLR.
The NEW SUPER SLR is an evolved version of the SUPER SLR, and when combined with the corresponding STI lever, it can provide strong braking power even with weak force.
It is different from the SLR-EV mentioned above, but the amount of brake lever pull is compatible with the SLR-EV.
This is the generation of Shimano’s dual-pivot brakes, often referred to as the old SUPER SLR because it is easily confused with the NEW SUPER SLR.
It requires more grip strength when braking than the NEW SUPER SLR.
Each technology and corresponding Shimano brakes
Let’s take a look at each grade of road bike and see which brakes use each technology.
Grades
SLR-EV
NEW SUPER SLR
OLD SUPER SLR
DURA-ACE
BR-9000 or later
BR-7900
BR-7800 or earlier
ULTEGRA
BR-6800 or later
BR-6700
BR-6600 or earlier
105
BR-5800 or later
BR-5700
BR-5600 or earlier
TIAGRA
-
BR-4600 or later
BR-4500
SORA
-
BR-3500 or later
BR-3400
SORA
-
BR-3500 or later
BR-3400
As of January 2021, only brakes of the 105 grade and above are compatible with the latest technology, SLR-EV; all brakes below TIAGRA, even the latest ones, stop at NEW SUPER SLR.
Although 105 is race-ready and preferred by hobby racers, it has been compatible with SLR-EV since the previous generation BR-5800, so this may be the reason why “if you are going to upgrade, at least go with 105”.
Shimano’s Current Brakes and Technology
Next, let’s take a look at the current generation of Shimano brakes for road bikes and which technologies they use.
Grades
SLR-EV
NEW SUPER SLR
旧SUPER SLR
DURA-ACE
BR-R9000
-
-
ULTEGRA
BR-R8000
-
-
105
BR-R7000
-
-
TIAGRA
-
BR-4700
-
SORA
-
BR-R3000
-
CLARIS
-
BR-R2000
-
Shimano’s current generation of brakes are all NEW SUPER SLR or higher.
The 105 and above are the latest technology “SLR-EV”, but all other grades are NEW SUPER SLR. In this sense, we can say that the technology is “105 and above, and the rest”.
Upper grade of the old generation vs. mid-range or lower grade of the current generation, which is better?
When buying brakes at a second-hand store, the question that comes to mind is: “older generation higher grade vs. current generation mid-range or lower grade”? That’s the question, isn’t it?
Let’s compare the current generation mid-grade and lower-grade brakes with the older generation upper-grade brakes.
The higher grade of one generation ago is better than the lower grade of the current generation
First of all, the following is a comparison between the higher grade of one generation ago and the current grade.
Grades
SLR-EV
NEW SUPER SLR
旧SUPER SLR
DURA-ACE
BR-9000
-
-
ULTEGRA
BR-6800
-
-
105
BR-5800
-
-
TIAGRA
-
BR-4700
-
SORA
-
BR-R3000
-
CLARIS
-
BR-R2000
-
The 105 and above are already SLR-EV one generation before the current R generation, so even the older models are better brakes than the middle and lower grade brakes of the current generation.
If you don’t consider the condition of the parts, then a used 105 or higher brakes of the previous generation is a better buy than a new lower grade of the current generation.
Two generations ago, the higher grade had the same technology as the current lower grade
So how does it compare to the brakes of the higher grade two generations ago?
Grades
SLR-EV
NEW SUPER SLR
旧SUPER SLR
DURA-ACE
-
BR-7900
-
ULTEGRA
-
BR-6700
-
105
-
BR-5700
-
TIAGRA
-
BR-4700
-
SORA
-
BR-R3000
-
CLARIS
-
BR-R2000
-
All are now NEW SUPER SLR. In other words, the current generation of mid- and lower-grade brakes can be viewed as “equivalent to the brakes two generations before the higher grade” in terms of technology.
Incidentally, the current generation of mid- and lower-grade brakes were released between 2015 and 2017, while the brakes two generations before the higher-grade brakes are products that were released between 2008 and 2010.
Considering the deterioration of the parts, it would be better to buy the current generation mid- and lower-grade brakes with equivalent technology than to buy brakes that are more than 10 years old.
I’ve been looking at the older generation of Shimano’s higher grade brakes and whether the current lower grade brakes are better.
In summary, here’s what we’ve learned
current generation vs current generation => current 105+ is better
1 generation old 105+ vs lower grade current => 1 generation old 105+.
2 generations ago 105+ vs current lower grade => current lower grade
When you want to replace or upgrade your brakes, it is quite difficult to decide which parts to choose, but if you look at it from the perspective of the technology installed, it will be easier to choose.
This section summarizes what tire inserts are and the advantages and disadvantages of using them, which have been attracting attention along with the spread of tubeless tires and have recently been used in professional road racing.
When looking for items to upgrade your road, MTB, or gravel bike tires, technical terms such as TPI, compound, and pattern appear in the descriptions. At first glance, tire specifications may seem difficult to understand, but if you keep only the important details in mind, your tire selection will be enhanced.
A torque wrench is a useful tool to have if you want to properly maintain your road bike or MTB. The following is a summary of what a torque wrench is and the advantages and disadvantages of torque management.
Bead raising" is an essential task with tubeless tires. However, there are times when it is easy to raise the bead, and other times when it does not raise at all despite your best efforts. In this issue, we will introduce a method to raise the bead of a tubeless tire that will not raise, considering the cause.
If you hear a strange "shuffling" noise coming from the disc rotor area of your disc brake bicycle, it could be disc rotor distortion. This section summarizes why disc rotor distortion occurs and how to correct the distortion.
The booster simplifies bead raising, which is the most difficult part of tubeless installation. We have compiled a list of air pumps with booster(boost functions) that are reassuring to have one.
Many "hookless rim" wheels are lightweight and cost-effective. What is hookless? We have compiled a list of advantages and disadvantages of hookless, as well as points to keep in mind when choosing.
Tubeless tires have seen a dramatic increase in the number of users over the past few years. Even with tubeless and tubeless ready tires, punctures cannot be reduced to zero. The following is a summary of the causes of punctures and how to deal with them.
When trying to change tire thickness on a road bike or other sport bicycle, it is important to know what tire size the wheel will allow. In this article, we will show you how to find out which tires are compatible with your wheel based on its specifications.
We have compiled a list of 12-speed chains that can be used with Shimano road bike and MTB components. Also about chain compatibility with chains from manufacturers other than Shimano.
Mounting adapters for bicycle disc brakes are essential when changing calipers with different standards or rotor sizes. This section explains the types of mount adapters, how to recognize them, and the model numbers of Shimano's mount adapters.
There are two types of lock rings for center locking disc brakes, inner serration and outer serration. The following is a summary of the differences and how to select the right one.
Mechanical disc brake calipers are easy to maintain and a low-cost way to upgrade from rim brake components to disc brakes. We have lined up models from major manufacturers and compared them.
With the popularity of gravel road bikes and the spread of disc brakes, the choice of road bike wheel size has become not only the standard 700C, but also 650B. In this issue, we will look at the differences between 700C and 650B, and the advantages and disadvantages of each.