Differences and how to choose between upper and lower front derailleurs

Posted at: Feb. 13, 2022

There are two types of front derailleurs, "top-route" and "down-route", depending on how the frame is routed. Here is a summary of the differences between the two, how to tell them apart, and what to look for when choosing one.

Table of contents

Difference between top and down route of front derailleur

Top route is common in cyclocross and MTB

A “top-route” front derailleur is a type of derailleur where the shift wire that pulls the front derailleur comes through the top of the derailleur.

In the case of a top-route front derailleur, the shift wire goes through the top tube as well as the rear brake, so it can be the furthest from the ground, which provides protection against mud.

In MTB and cyclo-cross bikes, there is a high possibility of mud from the ground, and if the shift wire is close to the ground, there is a possibility that the mud will clog the shift wire and prevent it from shifting gears.

However, today’s MTB and cyclocross bikes have more and more interior frames, so even with a lower pull, the shift wire is less affected by mud, etc. Therefore, a lower pull is increasingly being adopted.

Road bikes are basic down route

The front derailleur “down-route” refers to the type of shifting that is done by pulling the shift wire that comes through from below.

In the case of down-route, the shift wire from the STI lever passes under (or in) the down tube, and then passes through the wire from under the BB to the top to pull the front derailleur.

This method is mostly used for road bikes because they are designed to be ridden on paved roads, so there is no need for mud protection.

Top-route or down-route, the choice depends on the frame

Whether to use a top- or down-routed front derailleur depends on the frame.

Even if you buy a top-route front derailleur for mud protection, you cannot use a top-route front derailleur if the frame does not allow the shift wire to be routed through the top tube.

On the other hand, if you mistakenly buy a top-pull front derailleur for a bottom-pull frame, you will not be able to shift gears.

For example, the top images in this article are both of the band type FD-CX70, but the left one is the “top route” and the right one is the “down route. You can see that not only the position of the metal fittings that hold the shift wire is different, but also the structure that pulls the derailleur is completely different.

How to tell the difference between top and down routes

Most of Shimano’s current line of front derailleurs for road use have a downward pull, but be aware that some front derailleurs for cyclocross, which have “CX” in the model number, have a top pull.

Be careful when using the following two models of recent CX series front derailleurs.

FD-CX70
FD-CX50

MTB front derailleurs differ from product to product as to whether they have a top or bottom pull, so be sure to check the manufacturer’s official website.

Mechanics New Posts

Summary of hex wrench sizes to prepare for road bike maintenance.

For those who will be servicing their road bikes, we have compiled a list of hex wrench sizes that are commonly used for road bike maintenance and that you should have available.
Latex Butyl? Different tire tube materials and how to choose the right one.

There are two types of bicycle tire tubes, latex tubing and butyl tubing. The following is a summary of the differences between the two and which one you should choose.
Guide to Choosing Binding Pedals for Road Bikes

Binding pedals allow you to ride faster and more efficiently on your road bike. In this article, we will thoroughly explain what to look for when choosing binding pedals.
Summary of binding pedal cleat types and their respective characteristics

Cleats are the parts that connect binding pedals to shoes. Cleats are only one part, but each manufacturer has its own characteristics and differences. They are actually important parts that are linked to usability and their merits and demerits.
Advantages and disadvantages of putting sealant in road bike and MTB tires and how to choose

This section summarizes what sealants are for road bikes and MTBs, their advantages and disadvantages, and how to select sealants.
Types of valve extenders and how to select one

A valve extender, which extends the valve, is an essential item for operating deep-rim wheels on road bikes and other vehicles. The following is a summary of the different types of valve extenders, their differences, and how to select one.
Summary of brake shoes for carbon rim and wheel

When using rim brakes on carbon rim/wheels, it is essential to use special brake shoes to reduce braking force and damage to the rim. In this issue, we introduce a collection of brake shoes for carbon rim wheels.
Advantages and disadvantages of front single

The "front single" without front shifting is being increasingly adopted in MTB and gravel road bikes. This section summarizes the advantages and disadvantages of the front single.
Road Bike Stem Standards and How to Choose

The stem is an unassuming part, but actually has a significant impact on ride comfort and speed. In this issue, we summarize road bike stem standards and how to select one.
Advantages and disadvantages of tubeless and tubeless ready tires

Tubeless and tubeless ready tires are increasingly being adopted in the latest wheels. The following is a summary of the differences, advantages and disadvantages of each, and points to keep in mind when choosing.
Advantages and disadvantages of using CO2 cylinders

The CO2 cylinder is the preferred puncture repair inflator for expert road bike users. This section summarizes the advantages and disadvantages of using CO2 cylinders for inflating, and the differences from portable pumps.
Advantages and disadvantages of tubular tires

Tubular tires are the choice of users who are concerned about performance. In this issue, we summarize the advantages and disadvantages of tubular tires and what kind of users they match.
How to customize a road bike seat post and the effects you can get

Seat post customization has become a standard because it is easy and simple to do, even for beginners of road biking.
How do you determine the height of the handlebars on a road bike?

The "handlebar height" of a road bike has a significant impact on speed as well as ease of riding. This section summarizes what happens when you change the height and how to determine the right height.
Shimano road disc brake component compatibility summary

Shimano disc brake components for road use are difficult to select if you don't know about them. We have compiled a list of parts model numbers and their incompatibility, which can be difficult to understand.
What is the Q Factor? Measurement methods, how to determine appropriate values, and how to adjust

Q-factor is an important factor for improving pedaling efficiency. we summarize what Q-factor is, how to measure it, how to determine the proper value, and how to adjust it.
LOOK's Grades and Types of Binding Pedals for Road Use

LOOK is a highly regarded manufacturer of complete vehicles, and in this article, we'll take a look at the grades and types of LOOK's popular binding pedals for road use, and the differences between each model.
Summary of FSA cranks, grades and ratings

FSA cranks are often chosen as standard equipment for complete bikes. Here is a summary of their grades and why they are often rated low.
Choosing the right tires for a rainy road bike ride

Road bikes are often used for riding in the rain. In this article, we summarize tire selection for riding in the rain on a road bike.
What changes when you upgrade your Shimano rear derailleur?

One of the most modest component upgrades is the rear derailleur. Here is a summary of what changes when you upgrade your rear derailleur.