What Is Shimano Shadow RD? Features and Benefits
What is Shimano’s Shadow RD used in their latest rear derailleurs? This article explains its features and the benefits of choosing Shadow RD.
Modified at: Nov 2, 2023
Posted at: Mar 15, 2022
Q-factor is an important factor for improving pedaling efficiency. we summarize what Q-factor is, how to measure it, how to determine the proper value, and how to adjust it.
Table of contents
Sponsored Link
Q-factor refers to the distance between the pedal attachment points on the left and right crank arms.
This distance depends on the length of the bottom bracket (BB) spindle and the shape or bend of the crank arms, so the Q-factor is essentially determined by the combination of BB and crankset you choose.
For Shimano cranksets, the Q-factor is typically listed in the crank specifications.
A wider Q-factor results in a more bow-legged pedaling position, while a narrower Q-factor creates a more inward-legged position.
In cycling, a narrower stance allows your body’s center of gravity to align properly over the pedals, leading to more efficient pedaling. On the other hand, a wider stance spreads out your center of gravity, offering more stability and easier foot placement, but with some loss of power due to outward pedaling force.
As such, road bikes—where high cadence and steady pacing are common—tend to favor narrower Q-factors. Mountain bikes (MTBs), which often require dismounting and frequent foot placement on rough terrain, benefit from wider Q-factors for improved stability.
Even within road biking, the optimal Q-factor varies depending on the rider’s body. For example, riders with wider pelvises need a wider Q-factor. This is why smaller-framed female riders often end up pedaling bow-legged when using standard road cranksets.
The biggest benefit of selecting the correct Q-factor is achieving a pedaling motion that fits your body.
For example, in road biking, the goal is to pedal at a steady cadence while seated, keeping your legs moving in a straight vertical path. This ensures that all your downward force is transmitted directly to the pedals. It also helps keep the bike’s center of gravity balanced, stabilizing your pedaling.
Additionally, in road biking where aerodynamics matter, a narrower Q-factor lets riders keep a more compact posture, reducing wind resistance.
On the other hand, in mountain biking—where riders often stand on the pedals or put a foot down—the center of gravity being too centralized can make the bike unstable, increasing the risk of falls. For this reason, MTBs are designed with wider Q-factors to maintain better balance on uneven surfaces.
Q-Factor | Benefits & Effects | Drawbacks |
---|---|---|
Wider | More stable center of gravity Easier to put foot down |
Bow-legged pedaling Increased air resistance |
Narrower | More efficient pedaling Reduced air resistance |
Harder to maintain balance |
Measuring the Q-factor is simple — it’s just the distance between the pedal attachment points. However, since the crank arms are offset from each other, you’ll need to rotate the crank while measuring with a tape measure or similar tool.
Once you’ve measured your current crank’s Q-factor, compare it to your ideal pedaling position to see if it’s too wide or too narrow.
Try pedaling without your shoes clipped in, and shift your feet 1 cm inward or outward to find the most natural position. Once you’ve found that position, calculate the difference from your current Q-factor.
If the optimal position is inward, subtract twice the shift distance. If it’s outward, add twice the shift distance to determine your ideal Q-factor.
Sponsored Link
There are several ways to adjust Q-factor:
Method of Adjustment | Widen | Narrow |
---|---|---|
Replace crank | ✓ (May be limited by size) |
✓ (May be limited by size) |
Replace bottom bracket (BB) | ✓ (Depends on BB type) |
✓ (Depends on BB type) |
Adjust using pedals/cleats | ✓ | ✓ |
Use spacers | ✓ | - |
Let’s look at each method in more detail.
The most straightforward way to adjust Q-factor is by replacing the crank. This allows for a significant change in Q-factor, so it’s ideal when your current setup doesn’t suit you.
Each crank has a fixed Q-factor, so compare your current Q-factor to your optimal one and look for a crank that matches that spec.
If you’re switching to a narrower Q-factor crank, be sure to measure how narrow your bike frame allows. Just align the cranks parallel and measure the space between the crank arm and chainstay.
If this gap is too small, the new crank might interfere with the frame. To avoid this, leave at least 5mm of clearance.
Also, when replacing cranks, don’t forget to choose the appropriate crank arm length for your body and riding style.
Shimano Crank Length Lineup and How to Find the Best Crank Length
Crank length is a small difference, but it makes a big difference in riding style. In this article, we summarize Shimano's crank length lineup for road cranks and how to find the best crank length.
For standard square taper cranks, the bottom bracket has an integrated spindle, and various spindle lengths are available, allowing you to change the Q-factor just by swapping the BB.
For example, Shimano’s square taper BB model “BB-UN300” comes in lengths from 107 mm to 127 mm, letting you adjust Q-factor by up to 2 cm.
Note: Shimano’s Hollowtech II cranks have integrated spindles, so Q-factor cannot be adjusted via the BB in that case.
You can also fine-tune the Q-factor by adjusting the cleats on your shoes — no need to change the crank. This method allows for minor changes (a few millimeters).
Just slide the cleats sideways on your shoes. Be cautious not to move them too much, as this can shift your pedaling center and reduce efficiency. This method is best for small tweaks.
Note: Time-brand clipless pedals don’t allow for lateral cleat adjustment, but you can swap the left and right cleats to adjust the Q-factor.
If you want to widen your Q-factor, using crank or pedal spacers from third-party manufacturers is one option.
There are two main types of spacers: washer-type and bolt-extension-type.
Washer-type spacers allow for millimeter-level adjustments by stacking multiple washers. However, adding too many washers can prevent sufficient tightening torque or even damage your crank. Be sure to check compatibility with your crank and pedals before use.
When narrowing your Q-factor, don’t forget to also check your saddle position. A narrower Q-factor can naturally bring your legs closer together while pedaling, potentially causing your inner thighs to rub against the saddle.
If you notice rubbing after narrowing your Q-factor, try moving your saddle slightly backward. This moves the saddle’s nose away from your inner thigh and helps reduce friction.
If friction persists, try lowering the saddle height or consider switching to a different saddle. Look for models with narrower noses or women-specific short-nose saddles as potential solutions.
If you’ve widened your Q-factor and your current saddle no longer fits well, switching to a saddle with a wider rear (tail) can improve pedaling stability.
Sponsored Link
Lastly, let’s take a look at the Q-factor specifications for Shimano’s road bike cranksets:
Model | Grade | Q-Factor (mm) |
---|---|---|
FC-R9200 | DURA-ACE | 148 |
FC-R9100 | DURA-ACE | 146 |
FC-R8100 | ULTEGRA | 148 |
FC-R8000 | ULTEGRA | 146 |
FC-R7100 | 105 | 148 |
FC-R7000 | 105 | 146 |
FC-5800 | 105 | 146 |
FC-4700 | TIAGRA | 150 |
FC-RS400 | TIAGRA | 150.3 |
FC-R3000 | SORA | 150 |
FC-R3030 (3x9) | SORA | 158.8 |
FC-3550 | SORA | 150.3 |
FC-3503 (3x9) | SORA | 159.2 |
FC-R2000 | CLARIS | 150 |
FC-R2030 (3x8) | CLARIS | 158.8 |
FC-2450 | CLARIS | 152 |
FC-2403 (3x8) | CLARIS | 157.5 |
For race-grade cranksets from the 105 level and up, the standard Q-factor is typically 146mm. However, the latest DURA-ACE R9200 and ULTEGRA R8100 have widened slightly to 148mm.
In contrast, non-racing cranksets like TIAGRA and below start at around 150mm, and triple chainring models often reach around 158mm — over 10mm wider than race-grade cranks. This likely reflects the difference between racing and general-purpose designs.
If you want to narrow your Q-factor but are already using a 105 or higher crank, changing the crank won’t help. However, upgrading from a TIAGRA or lower crank to a 105 or higher can reduce your Q-factor by 2–13mm.
Sponsored Link
Understanding bicycle crank sets
The crankset is an important part of a bicycle. The crankset itself is expensive and cannot be removed without special tools, so it is not an easily accessible customization, but it is also a part that has a large impact on your riding.
PCD compatibility chart for cranks and chainrings
We have compiled a PCD compatibility chart to use as a guide when replacing the chainring on your crank.
Essential Special Tools for Installing and Servicing Shimano Hollowtech 2
Hollowtech 2" is the standard adopted by the latest Shimano front cranks. We have compiled a list of special tools required for installation and maintenance of "Hollowtech 2", which is unavoidable when upgrading to higher grade front cranks.
Shimano Crank Length Lineup and How to Find the Best Crank Length
Crank length is a small difference, but it makes a big difference in riding style. In this article, we summarize Shimano's crank length lineup for road cranks and how to find the best crank length.
Summary of FSA cranks, grades and ratings
FSA cranks are often chosen as standard equipment for complete bikes. Here is a summary of their grades and why they are often rated low.
Q Factor: Measurement, Determination, and Adjustment
Q-factor is an important factor for improving pedaling efficiency. we summarize what Q-factor is, how to measure it, how to determine the proper value, and how to adjust it.
Q Factor: Measurement, Determination, and Adjustment
Q-factor is an important factor for improving pedaling efficiency. we summarize what Q-factor is, how to measure it, how to determine the proper value, and how to adjust it.
Types and selection of drop handlebars for road bikes
There are three main ways to select drop handlebars for road bikes, material, drop shape, and flat shape. Let's take a look at the key points and advantages and disadvantages of each.
5 important factors in choosing a road bike frame size
When buying a road bike, frame size is one of the most difficult issues. We have picked up five essential points for choosing the frame size to help you figure out how to select the right frame for your body.
Determining the height of road bike handlebars
The "handlebar height" of a road bike has a significant impact on speed as well as ease of riding. This section summarizes what happens when you change the height and how to determine the right height.
Road Bike Stem Standards and How to Choose
The stem is an unassuming part, but actually has a significant impact on ride comfort and speed. In this issue, we summarize road bike stem standards and how to select one.
Customizing a road bike seat post and its effects
Seat post customization has become a standard because it is easy and simple to do, even for beginners of road biking.
What Is Shimano Shadow RD? Features and Benefits
What is Shimano’s Shadow RD used in their latest rear derailleurs? This article explains its features and the benefits of choosing Shadow RD.
Shimano Chain Compatibility for Road, MTB, and Hybrid Bikes
An overview of Shimano chain compatibility across road bikes, mountain bikes, and hybrid bikes. Includes guidance on how to choose the right chain for your drivetrain.
Shimano ESSA Lineup and Compatibility with Existing 8-Speed Parts
An overview of Shimano's newly released 8-speed component group "ESSA" and its compatibility with existing 8-speed parts.
SRAM Cassette Compatibility Guide
Compatibility guide for SRAM cassettes used in road and MTB bikes. Find matching drivetrains and wheels easily.
Compatibility Guide for SRAM MTB Components
A detailed explanation of compatibility between SRAM MTB components. This guide outlines which parts can be used together and which combinations are not compatible.
Road and MTB Sprockets Compatibility Overview
A guide to the compatibility between road and MTB sprockets, explaining whether they can be used together with different components.
Shimano CUES Cassette Compatibility Guide
A detailed guide to the compatibility of Shimano CUES series cassettes. Includes an overview of compatible rear derailleurs, chains, and wheels.
Shimano Hydraulic Brake Hose and Connector Standards Guide
An explanation of the differences between Shimano’s hydraulic brake hoses BH90 and BH59, the types of connecting bolts, and how to choose the right hose for your brake system—including key points to watch out for.
Types and Compatibility of Shimano Di2 Batteries
The Di2 battery is the core of the Shimano Di2 system, influencing the overall system layout. This article explains the different types and their compatibility.
Shimano Di2 Wire Types and Compatibility
Overview of Shimano Di2 electric wire types and their compatibility with Di2 components.
How to Identify Shimano Di2 Generations
Explains the generational differences in Shimano Di2 components and their compatibility. Includes a list of component series and their corresponding generations.
In-Depth Guide to Shimano 12-Speed Cassette Compatibility
A detailed explanation of the key compatibility factors when using Shimano's 12-speed cassettes—specifically the required wheel (freehub) and drivetrain, which differ significantly from previous 11-speed systems.
Perfect Guide to Shimano 11-Speed Cassette Compatibility
A detailed explanation of two key compatibility factors when using Shimano 11-speed cassettes: the required wheel (freehub) and drivetrain.
Perfect Guide to Shimano 10-Speed Cassette Compatibility
A detailed explanation of two key compatibility factors when using Shimano 10-speed cassettes: the required wheel (freehub) and drivetrain.
In-Depth Guide to Shimano 9-Speed Cassette Compatibility
A comprehensive explanation of two key compatibility factors when using Shimano 9-speed cassettes: the required wheel (freehub) and drivetrain.
Shimano I-SPEC Shift Lever Mount Standards Explained
A complete guide to Shimano's I-SPEC shift lever mount standards, covering features, differences between models, and compatibility.
Shimano Hydraulic Disc Brake Standards and Selection Guide
Unlike mechanical brakes that only pull a cable, hydraulic disc brakes come with various standards and technologies depending on the manufacturer. This article highlights Shimano’s hydraulic disc brake technologies and standards, along with key points to consider when selecting one.
Shimano CUES Components Lineup and Compatibility Guide
A comprehensive guide to Shimano's new CUES component group for MTB and lifestyle categories, including gear ratios, part lineup, and compatibility with traditional components.
TPU Inner Tube: Features, Pros, and Cons for Road Bikes and MTB
TPU inner tubes are gaining attention as the third force in bicycle tires. We summarize its features, advantages and disadvantages of using it on Road bikes and MTBs, and major manufacturers.
Shimano Mechanical Brake Levers for MTB and Hybrid Bike
Shimano mechanical brake levers are now few and far between. The following is a summary of the current model lineup, specifications, and compatible components.